shieldvsumbrelOS
Two self-hosted projects, compared on the numbers selfhost.directory tracks live: score, popularity, release cadence and setup effort.
| shield | umbrelOS | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 50/100 | 73/100 |
| Rank in category | #5 of 15 in Backup Management | #2 of 22 in Home Server |
| GitHub stars | 402 | 12 474 |
| Stars, last 30 days | — | +439 |
| Stable releases, 12 months | 2 | 7 |
| Latest release | v9.0.2 · 11 Aug 2026 | 2.0.0 · 22 Sept 2026 |
| Setup | Advanced | Moderate |
| Official Docker image | Yes | No |
| License | MIT | Other |
| Main language | Go | Typescript |
Which one should you pick?
umbrelOS scores 73/100 against 50/100 for shield, so it is the safer default.
umbrelOS ships more often: 7 stable releases in the past year, against 2 for shield.
If you want the quickest setup, umbrelOS is easier to run; shield needs more configuration.
umbrelOS is growing faster right now (+439 stars in 30 days).
shield details →umbrelOS details →
Swap a project
Keep shield, compare it with
Keep umbrelOS, compare it with