Immichvsyoutube-dl
Two self-hosted projects, compared on the numbers selfhost.directory tracks live: score, popularity, release cadence and setup effort.
| Immich | youtube-dl | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 93/100 | 51/100 |
| Rank in category | #1 of 19 in Photo Galleries | #6 of 12 in Video |
| GitHub stars | 117 525 | 402 |
| Stars, last 30 days | +2 609 | — |
| Stable releases, 12 months | 22 | 0 |
| Latest release | v3.3.5 · 21 Oct 2026 | — |
| Setup | Moderate | Easy |
| Official Docker image | Yes | Yes |
| License | AGPL-3.0 | MIT |
| Main language | Typescript | Python |
Which one should you pick?
Immich scores 93/100 against 51/100 for youtube-dl, so it is the safer default.
Immich ships more often: 22 stable releases in the past year, against 0 for youtube-dl.
If you want the quickest setup, youtube-dl is easier to run; Immich needs more configuration.
Immich is growing faster right now (+2 609 stars in 30 days).
Immich details →youtube-dl details →
Swap a project
Keep Immich, compare it with
Keep youtube-dl, compare it with