selfhost.directory

The index of self-hostable projects — ranked, categorized and served with live updates.
Own your data and stop giving it to big tech.

CommentovsTalkyard

Two self-hosted Disqus alternatives, compared on the numbers selfhost.directory tracks live: score, popularity, release cadence and setup effort.

CommentoTalkyard
Score53/10055/100
Rank in category#5 of 5 in Comments#35 of 75 in Social Networks & Forums
GitHub stars—1 813
Stars, last 30 days—+0
Stable releases, 12 months02
Latest release—tyse-v1.2026.003-f220a7d9f-regular · 26 May 2026
SetupModerateAdvanced
Official Docker imageYesNo
LicensemitAGPL-3.0
Main language—Typescript

Which one should you pick?

Talkyard scores 55/100 against 53/100 for Commento, so it is the safer default.

Talkyard ships more often: 2 stable releases in the past year, against 0 for Commento.

If you want the quickest setup, Commento is easier to run; Talkyard needs more configuration.

Key differences

  • License: Commento is mit, Talkyard is AGPL-3.0.
  • Only Commento ships an official Docker image.
  • Features only Commento lists: Ad-free, Automated spam detection, Comment Voting, Disqus Import and 6 more.
  • Features only Talkyard lists: Anonymous posting, Automatic HTTPS / Let's Encrypt, Automatic software updates, Custom Branding and 11 more.

Swap a project

Keep Commento, compare it with
Keep Talkyard, compare it with